Sad for "real" jazz

[Lois Gilbert]

By Dan Ouellette

NEW YORK (Billboard) - Wynton Marsalis is arguably the most recognized name in jazz, for his achievements as a performer and ambassador for the genre. His roles as artistic director for Jazz at Lincoln Center and fundraiser for its new Frederick P. Rose Hall in New York have won him deserved praise.

But the charts tell a different story of who's who in jazz. Fellow New Orleans native Harry Connick (news) Jr. far outranks Marsalis, claiming the No. 1 spot on the year-end Top Jazz Artists recap. Connick's release "Only You" (Columbia/Sony Music) is No. 1 on the Top Jazz Album tally.

The Wynton Marsalis Quartet is the No. 9 act on the Top Jazz Artists chart, while the quartet's debut for Blue Note, "The Magic Hour," ends the year at No. 13 on the album recap.

Connick scored big with "Only You," a rare platinum-selling jazz album. It's a fully orchestrated vocal collection of classic songs from the '50s and '60s, featuring Connick crooning into the heart of such gems as Ray Noble's "The Very Thought of You" and Allen Toussaint's "All These Things." While his steeped-in-Sinatra voice is the draw, Connick also delivers fine piano breaks and frees his horn players, on occasion, to take a jazz stretch.

Connick also holds down the No. 3 spot on the Top Jazz Albums chart with his Columbia Christmas disc, "Harry for the Holidays," released in 2003 and recently certified platinum. Connick currently is involved in a spinoff project, the animated TV special "The Happy Elf." Connick serves as host and narrator as well as score composer and producer. It will premiere during the 2005 holiday season.

KRALL SCORES TWICE

Diana Krall claims the No. 2 and No. 4 positions on the Top Jazz Albums chart with, respectively, her 2004 CD, "The Girl in the Other Room," and 2002's "Live in Paris," both on Verve.

The new disc marks a major shift in Krall's artistic role from song stylist (a la Tony Bennett (news)) to composer. For the first time in her career, she recorded originals, all six of which were written with husband Elvis Costello (news).

Key to the success of the disc is Krall's stretch on the keys, making this her strongest jazz outing. It obviously hasn't disappointed fans of her earlier recordings, which leaned on reworkings of standards for success.

Other strong showings on the Top Jazz Albums chart include vocal outings by young singer Renee Oldstead (her self-titled debut on 143/Reprise/Warner Bros.), chanteuse Jane Monheit (her major-label premiere, "Taking a Chance on Love," on Sony Classical) and Billie Holiday sound-alike Madeleine Peyroux (her long-awaited sophomore disc, "Careless Love," on Rounder).

Meanwhile, Norah Jones (news) once again holds the No. 1 spot on the year-end Top Contemporary Jazz Artists chart on the strength of her album "Come Away With Me" (Blue Note), the No. 1 title on the Top Contemporary Jazz Albums recap.

Jones' second Blue Note album, "Feels Like Home," released this year, has not been categorized as a jazz release on the charts. Like its predecessor, it has sold multiplatinum and kept Jones on the road throughout the year. A series of performances in Asia, Australia, New Zealand and Japan are scheduled to keep her busy into the middle of 2005. No new recording projects are in the wings.

CROSSOVER CLOUT

Jones' closest challenger has been young British singer/pianist/songwriter Jamie Cullum, whose debut, "Twentysomething" (Universal/Verve/VG), takes the No. 2 spot on the Top Contemporary Jazz Albums chart.
On the disc Cullum delivers standards with a new twist and stomp. He also raises the hip factor with fresh takes on rock tunes from Jimi Hendrix to Radiohead, and throws in enough catchy and rollicking originals to offer an eclectic package of extroverted jazz-pop crossover.

Smooth jazz saxophonist Kenny G and trumpeter Chris Botti (news) rank at No. 3 and No. 6, respectively, on the Top Contemporary Jazz Artists chart thanks to the success of their albums "Ultimate Kenny G" (BMG Heritage/RMG) and "A Thousand Kisses Deep" (Columbia/Sony Music).

Kenny G and Botti and have new fourth-quarter albums ("At Last ... The Duets Album," on Arista, and "When I Fall in Love," on Columbia, respectively) that will no doubt place them high in next year's rankings.

A significant story of 2004 is how two leading Top Jazz Imprints -- Columbia, which ranks at No. 1, and Blue Note, at No. 3 -- did not release straight-ahead jazz albums.

They both banked on past and present successes -- most prominently Connick and Jones. The job of giving worthwhile new talent an opportunity to shine was taken by the increasingly important indies.

Given that the two imprints have a history of breaking new and important artists, jazz fans can only hope they both open their doors wide in 2005 to upstart jazz instrumentalists and vocalists.

Reuters/Billboard

[Tom Storer]

All this means is that "real" jazz doesn't sell well compared to commercially oriented vocal jazz (or ersatz jazz). No surprise!

[Lois Gilbert]

I know Tom, no surpise but one keeps hoping!

[Nathaniel Catchpole]

No, I think it shows that writers for Billboard are only interested in their silly charts and can happily ignore that the ten CDs that sold the most (in certain selected record shops, not all, including most indies) don't represent the overall mileu of releases/purchases, or the fact that outside of big names, many people are buying a lot of different records by different people, or different records by the same person; not just x's new release because Billboard's mates tell them to.

[Scott Yanow]

Billboard's jazz charts rarely make much sense, and their contemporary jazz chart tends to be nonsensical.

Blue Note did not release any straightahead jazz albums this year? What about the Wynton Marsalis CD, or many others that aren't on the Billboard charts? A bit of a contradiction.

Gee, so does this mean pop albums outsell jazz?

[graypencil]

disgusting, disheartening, dismal ..

..but not surprising somehow ..

faux jazz for martini parties and esy listening ..

[Richardo Caerleoni]

"Wynton Marsalis is arguably the most recognized name ..."

What, Who? !!! Arguably ...

Now listening to Cliiford in Paris...

RC.

[Gary Sisco]

Billboard uses only SoundScan sales for its figures -- meaning, essentially, corporate schlock stores. Almost no independent stores' sales are factored in, since they can't afford SoundScan technology. Almost no mail orders. Or record clubs. Or sales at gigs. Or direct from label sales. I'm not sure about giants like Amazon. But you get the point.

Almost all sources of jazz sales don't count in SoundScan figures and hence don't count in Billboard (or anything else that references alleged sales).

Marsalis it the most recognized name among people who don't buy much if any jazz. Krall as well.

[Dr Dave]

After reading so much Gary Giddens, I am now embarking on a "Be Kind To Diana Krall" campaign. I haven't heard any of her new stuff with Costello, but you know, she's been pretty good over the years. So she's not great. She plays (played?) jazz, and she sells.

[Gary Sisco]

Good for her.

[coltrane]

Billboard uses only SoundScan sales for its figures -- meaning, essentially, corporate schlock stores. Almost no independent stores' sales are factored in, since they can't afford SoundScan technology. Almost no mail orders. Or record clubs. Or sales at gigs. Or direct from label sales.

Thank you very much Gary.

[Steve Reynolds]

liked Gary's last post

so she's "good" - if she is, I don't know - and I really don't give two shits

what I do know is that there are *great* jazz musicians among us who get zero acclaim - there was a day when the great ones did

people need to wake up to the wonder


Standing on a Whale Fishing for Minnows

[clinthopson]

Hey folks, we're a tiny minority.

I can't get too down on Norah Jones' successthough, after all we have a family financial interest in her career.

[amerijazz]

I'm usually willing to give anyone the benefit of the doubt, but I've never understood the appeal of Mr. Connick. I swear if I had to listen to that lousy, off-key version of "It Must Have Been Ol' Santa Claus" one more time this past holiday season, I would have slammed my nuts in the car door.

Jamie Cullum seems to me to have been cut from the same cloth as Connick, but he's young so we'll see where he goes. It's kind of a double-sided coin: the younger performers aren't really in the jazz mainstream and draw attention and funds away from those who are, but there's always the chance that they will lead listeners towards the real thing. I've managed to meet a few people who took the long road from Kenny G to Kenny Garrett and were happy to arrive at the real deal.

[amerijazz]

A significant story of 2004 is how two leading Top Jazz Imprints -- Columbia, which ranks at No. 1, and Blue Note, at No. 3 -- did not release straight-ahead jazz albums.

Patently untrue. Bill Charlap's "Somewhere", issued by Blue Note in March, definitely qualifies. One could argue for Greg Osby's "Public". Or Don Byron's "Ivey-Divey", even though he's not exactly nailing Prez note-for-note.