|
Some nice moments, especially in the original ballad, but I feel the performance of 'Golden Lady' is marred by Ms Warfield's difficulties with the key. Eb (the 'Real Book' key) was Stevie Wonder's key on the original 'Innervisions' recording; Ms Warfield would have better off in G or Ab. That would have been a major improvement in this case- either that, or have it sung by a man, if transposition would have been too difficult.
Too often, the inclusion of a singer is an afterthought, and then he/she is made to feel unprofessional if they can't sing in the 'standard' key.
Players need to consider what key is best for a singer's range, and transpose when necessary.
Of course, singers should also consider what they can and can't do well, and say 'put it in my key, or get someone else'...
__________________
Scotty Wright - jazz voice
view my videos at JazzVision
Last edited by ScottyWright; July-6th-2009 at 07:33 PM.
|